America's #1 Mortgage Broker

head_left_image

Will VantageScore Bring Consistency?

VantageScoreSM Solutions, LLC, is a joint venture between the three powerhouse credit scoring bureaus, Experian®, Equifax, and TransUnion®. Launched in March 2006, VantageScore has two very ambitious goals: 1) to reduce credit score inconsistencies across the three companies, and 2) to help consumers better assess and interpret their credit scores. In the past, credit scores could vary significantly across these three companies, creating inconsistencies that made it difficult for lenders to interpret and for consumers to understand.

To accomplish these goals, VantageScore offers credit-score calculation based on a standardized algorithm used by all three parent companies. With this uniform system in place to calculate credit scores, variation across the three companies is now limited to any discrepancies in the specific credit information collected by each company. VantageScore also offers an overall credit score and grade based on the level of predictive credit risk calculated by their standard model. Utilizing the familiar A through F grading scale used by educational institutions, VantageScore helps consumers understand the significance of their overall number score by attaching a letter grade.

It's unknown if VantageScore will be a success or what affect it will have on the current Fair Isaac Corporation (FICO) system. FICO, however, is presently pursuing legal action against VantageScore Solutions, citing anti-trust and unfair competition violations.

This article is provided by Brian Brady of World Wide Credit Corporation and is reprinted with permission from the the Loan Toolbox.  World Wide Credit Corporation is a San Diego-based mortgage firm.  World Wide Credit Corporation has Spanish-speaking loan consultants available to homeowners and home buyers needing mortgage advice. 

CLICK HERE FOR A SPANISH TRANSLATION 

Comments

Brian,

I read about this, it's sounds like their ultimate Goal is to help, so it sounds good to me!!

Thanks for this,

Tom Weiss

Posted by Thomas Weiss (Thomas R. Weiss) over 2 years ago
Brian - sounds good, a system that could be understood by the consumer and consistent.  How do we push it into the mainstream?
Posted by Aziz Abdur-Raoof,Howard Co. Real Estate Scoop (RE/MAX Rewards) over 2 years ago

Brian,

Thanks for the info. So is this currently being used at this point? Have you compared the accuracy to FICO?

Posted by Orange Co. Real Estate~Lynda Eisenmann, Broker-Owner, CRS,CRB,GRI,SRES, Brea, CA (Preferred Home Brokers) over 2 years ago
I for one am skeptical.  My experience with the credit bureaus has taught me that they are not consumer friendly.  Any projects that they work together on gives me pause.  While I'm not a fan of Fair Issacs, and Vantage Score sounds positive, I think that caution is indicated.
Posted by Kate Bourland Empowering America to Live Debt Free (Financial Solutions Inc.) over 2 years ago
Brian -0 Seems like after a year there would be some quantifiable results...hmmm?
Posted by Laguna Homes|Laguna Condos| Laguna Real Estate|Marlene Bridges (Sherman Smith & Associates) over 2 years ago

Folks,

I haven't heard an update about the Vantage Score product.  These questions tell me I have more homework to do. 

Posted by America's #1 Mortgage Broker/858-777-9751 over 2 years ago

I feel the goal is to make the scores make more sense to the average consumer...

most "grades" are out of a 100% system so an 85 to them is less than perfect even though 850 is perfect in credit

I think Vantage Score still masks the algorithm so credit related professionals will still have issues explaining to a client why their 650 is now a 725 but worse than before (just an example)

Posted by Boca Raton & Lake Worth Florida Real Estate Broker over 2 years ago
Brian, thanks for the post.  I am pretty skeptical of this new system, because the main problem that will skew the scores is still going to be inaccurate information on the credit report: I think that is what needs to be addressed, as well as a simplification of the FICO score.
Posted by James Hershiser, Loan Officer for RELC, Inc. (RELC, Inc.) over 2 years ago
2 years ago, the 3 bureaus were going to launch a new scoring system with 1000 as the perfect score, goal was to reduce inconsistencies.  Is this the same system?
Posted by Rich Sweum (Golf Savings Bank) over 2 years ago

Brian:

It will be interesting to see how VantageScore evolves.

Perhaps even more important, I want to commend your Spanish language initiative! 

Posted by Roberta Murphy - Carlsbad Real Estate North County San Diego Realtor (San Diego Previews * Previews Luxury Real Estate) over 2 years ago

Participate



(optional)
What does the graphic say?